American Idol is celebrating Easter with songs of faith as the top 20 contestants are revealed and four artists are eliminated in Season 23.
Season 23 of American Idol brought emotion, inspiration, and fierce competition during its Easter Sunday episode on April 20. With a theme centered around songs of faith, each contestant delivered heartfelt performances in hopes of earning America’s vote. Following the nationwide vote from last week’s performances, the top 20 artists were revealed—and four hopefuls were sent home.
Opening the night was platinum ticket winner Canaan James Hill, who blew the judges away with his passionate version of “Better Days” by Le’Andria Johnson. Lionel Richie called it a “performance to be remembered,” while Carrie Underwood praised his incredible vocals and encouraged him to embrace stage presence more fully.
Drew Ryn followed with “Yellow” by Coldplay, earning a standing ovation. Although her song choice was unconventional for the theme, the judges were impressed. Underwood commended her creativity, and Luke Bryan called her a “diamond in the rough.”
Desmond Roberts earned his spot with an energetic rendition of “Worship” by Jon Batiste. Lionel Richie and Carrie Underwood both lauded the excitement and vocal control he brought to the stage, while Luke Bryan marveled at his entertainment value.
Another platinum ticket holder, Filo, stunned the judges with “Bridge Over Troubled Water” by Simon & Garfunkel. His performance started quietly but built to an emotional crescendo that brought all three judges to their feet.
Josh King kept the momentum going with “You Are So Beautiful” by Joe Cocker, a touching tribute to his mom. The performance melted Carrie Underwood’s heart and impressed Luke Bryan with its subtle strength.
Thunderstorm Artis showed a new side of himself with “Reckless Love” by Cory Asbury, creating what Luke Bryan called a “big Christian rock concert” moment. His family cheered him on from the audience.
Amanda Barise soared with “If I Ain’t Got You” by Alicia Keys, earning a standing ovation. Lionel Richie raved about her emotional growl, and Underwood was thrilled she made the classic song her own. Luke Bryan called it her shining moment.
John Foster performed his original song “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” a tribute to a lost friend. Luke Bryan admitted John had been a wildcard but said this performance erased all doubt.
The youngest contestant, Mattie Pruitt, wowed with “Rescue” by Lauren Daigle. Her signature vocal “cry” earned praise from all three judges. Lionel Richie said her voice has an instant identity.
Olivier Bergeron closed out the top 20 selections from night two in Hawaii with “Stay” by Rihanna. The judges acknowledged his growth and urged him to push even further.
From night one in Hawaii, Breanna Nix was the first to hear she made it. Her performance of “Up to the Mountain” was solid and consistent, with Carrie Underwood praising her reliability.
Victor Solomon owned the stage with “For Every Mountain.” Luke Bryan called the performance uniquely his own, and Lionel Richie described it as “electrifying.”
Baylee Littrell, son of Backstreet Boy Brian Littrell, performed his dad’s song “Gone Without Goodbye.” Carrie Underwood loved the vocal range, and the judges encouraged him to keep the pressure on.
Isaiah Misailegalu brought his relaxed, soulful style to “Give You Blue” by Allen Stone. Carrie Underwood noted the joy he conveyed, while Luke Bryan admired his smooth delivery and unique voice.
Gabby Samone delivered a jaw-dropping version of “I Am Changing” from Dreamgirls. Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie called her a star, but Carrie Underwood declared her a “superstar.”
Slater Nalley sang “Soulshine” by The Allman Brothers Band, staying true to his roots. The judges loved his ease and consistency, encouraging him to keep being himself.
Zaylie Windsor performed “Silver Springs” and showed growth, though the judges pushed her to lean more into powerful vocal moments in future performances.
Jamal Roberts brought the house down with “Forever” by Jason Nelson. Lionel Richie called his vocals “outrageous,” while Luke Bryan praised his unique blend of old-school and current style.
Ché delivered a heartfelt “Redemption Song,” showcasing his strong voice and earning high praise across the board. Luke Bryan even said Ché has one of his favorite voices ever.
Finally, platinum ticket winner Kolbi Jordan belted “Amazing Grace,” closing the top 20 selections on a high note. Carrie Underwood called it “amazing,” and Bryan described it as “breathtaking.”
Unfortunately, the Easter celebration also came with farewells. Kyana Fanene and Grayson Torrence were eliminated from the night two group after receiving the fewest votes. From night one, MKY and Penny Samar were also sent home.
With the top 20 now locked in, the competition heats up as only 14 will advance after America votes during the Monday, April 21 episode.
American Idol airs Sundays and Mondays at 8/7c on ABC.
